Greetings Earthkind!
As part of this Readers’ Advisory class, I am required to read and annotate five books from five different genres.
This week, I am annotating a book from the Gentle Reads genre. I believe this book just barely fits in the genre, though I do believe it fits. Were I more familiar with this author and had I more time, I probably would have chosen a book that better represents the genre.
Author: Elaine Viets
Title: Checked Out: A Dead-End Job Mystery
Genre: Gentle Reads, Cozy Mystery
Publication Date: 5 May 2015
Number of Pages: 276 (I read a hardcover version from the library)
Geographical Setting: Florida. Fort Lauderdale, Flora Park
Time Period: Modern-Day (Snapchat and Facebook are referenced at one point)
Series (If applicable): #14 of A Dead-End Job Mystery Series
Plot Summary: Private Investigators Helen and Phil Hawthorne have their hands full of cases. First, they are hired to investigate a 21-year-old’s missing ruby necklace. Then, Helen is hired by the daughter of a late wealthy man to find a missing million-dollar painting that had likely been inside of a book that was donated to the Flora Park Library along with three hundred other boxes from his estate.
Helen is hired as a volunteer for the library, which causes quite a stir in this wealthy, status-is-everything town so she can search the collection of donated items. Along the way, Helen learns the library could have a ghost that is inspiring panic from the library board.
When a dead body appears, Helen is determined to solve the mystery of their death and find the missing painting.
Subject Headings: (Some pulled from the NoveList Plus listing) Women Detectives; Murder Investigation; Undercover Operations; Private Investigators; Husband and Wife; Hawthorne, Helen; Theft Ring; Library
Appeal: This is a very genteel novel that is formal and leisurely, with a bit of fun and mystery mixed in. The characters and the smallness of the two communities are the main focus.
3 terms that best describe this book: Library; Mystery; Theft
3 Relevant Fiction Works and Authors:
- Jenn McKinlay
- Library Lover’s Mysteries
- Writes cozy mysteries and gentle reads that take place in small communities and libraries and that feature a female amateur sleuth as the main character.
- Miranda James
- Cat in the Stacks Mysteries
- Southern Ladies Mysteries
- Writes cozy mysteries that take place in small, wealthy, southern communities. The main characters accidentally become involved in helping to solve murder cases while still having to go about their regular lives and jobs.
- Mary Daheim
- Emma Lord Mysteries
- Bed-and-Breakfast Mysteries
- Her cozy mysteries feature female characters with a sense of humor, much like Helen. She focuses on scene setting, day-to-day life, and characters.
My Personal Thoughts:
To be honest, I wasn’t as much of a fan of this book as some of the other cozy mysteries I’ve read. It’s fairly formal and reminds me of “the old days,” but it wasn’t as leisurely as I would have liked it.
The author used elements of suspense, such as shorter chapters, to drive the story forward, and I didn’t get to “enjoy” the different settings much. That’s not to say that the suspenseful elements weren’t useful or good; they just weren’t what I was expecting.
I love Helen, who is strong, funny, and very much someone I would love to be like “when I grow up,” and I can definitely agree with her about being a Page.
I really loved this line, “‘Exactly what are you doing next, Ms. Hawthorne?’ ‘Going to talk to someone pleasant,’ Helen said. ‘Good afternoon.'”
One of the officers was a little stereotypical and hard to believe, and I would like to have seen more from him.
I also would have liked to see more of Paris, the library cat.
Additionally, the inclusion of an epilogue was a nice touch that I hadn’t seen in a cozy mystery before.
All of that said, I would still read more from this series, and I believe my judgments come from reading too many other cozy mysteries that I love dearly, which are set in libraries.
Thanks for taking time to read this review, and until next time, Happy Reading!